January 14, 2014

Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie

Name: Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie
Yield: 1 pie
Ingredients: 1 baked pie crust; 1/4 C butter; 1/2 C heavy cream; 8 oz semi sweet chocolate chips; 2 C whole milk; 1/2 C sugar; 1/4 tsp kosher salt; 2 egg yolks; 1 egg; 1/4 C corn starch; 1 oz butter; 1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract; 1 banana (sliced); sweetened whipped cream

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie – Over the weekend I did a little teasing on Instagram and Facebook by posting a picture of this pie and you guys went kind of crazy. I wasn’t actually planning on posting this for another couple of weeks but I thew caution to the wind and here I am. Because really, what’s going to happen? I have to post pulled pork tacos in a few weeks instead of this pie? I think I can live with that.

My hubby and I have a birthday agreement that on my birthday we go out somewhere I want to go and on his birthday I cook him whatever his little heart desires. Sometimes he goes a little over-board but its fun and gives me a chance to make something I wouldn’t ordinarily make. This year he chose a big pot of crab and shrimp gumbo, dirty rice (minus the chicken livers), french bread, and this banana cream pie. It was his idea to include a layer of chocolate ganache beneath the custard and at first I thought it was a totally original idea. But it only took Google a total of 8.7 seconds to burst that little bubble. Turns out it’s been done but let me tell you, it’s for good reason! This pie is so darn good! Let’s make it!

How to Make This Black Bottom Banana Cream Pie

You’ll start out with a pre-baked pie crust. I decided to use a frozen shell (Marie Calendar’s frozen crusts are my favorite) to save on time but making your crust is pretty easy peasy if you follow my no-fail recipe. No matter what crust you use, before baking use a fork and give the crust a good poking. This will keep the crust from puffing up and shrinking during baking.

While you’re letting the crust cool, start working on the chocolate ganache. Ganache sounds super fancy but it’s really just a mixture of cream, chocolate, and sometimes butter. Heat the cream and butter on the stovetop until the butter is melted and the cream has just come to a simmer.

Pour the cream and butter over some good-quality semi-sweet chocolate chips and stir, stir, stir. It will look gloppy and gross at first but once all the chocolate melts it’s shiny, smooth, and gorgeous.

See what I mean? It’s purrrrdy.

Pour about half of the mixture into the bottom of your cooled pie crust. You want enough to create about a 1/4″ layer (or more if you want it REALLY chocolately). Set aside the remaining ganache to drizzle over the top of the pie when complete.

My Tip For Homemade Custard

Next up: Custard! When I make homemade puddings or custards I always use whole milk. Yes, it add more calories. Yes, I know it’s January and you’re trying to eat better. But just do it. If you REALLY want to you can use 2%, but under no circumstances should you attempt to use anything under that. The extra fat keeps the custard smooth and creamy and I take no responsibility for an icky custard.

You’ll heat the milk and half of the sugar on the stovetop until it is at almost a boil. While it’s heating combine the other half of the sugar, 2 egg yolks, 1 whole egg, and some cornstarch in a separate bowl, whisking until smooth.

Once your milk is just about boiling, use a ladle or small cup to take some of that hot milk and whisk it into the egg mixture. This process is called “Tempering” and brings the eggs slowly up to temperature so they don’t curdle when they are added to the pot. Continue adding hot milk and whisking until the egg mixture is warm to the touch.

Whisk the warmed-up egg mixture into the pot and DON”T STOP WHISKING! It might take just a few minutes, it might take up to 10, but whatever you do, don’t stop stirring until the custard is thickened, glossy, has come to a boil for 1 minute, and is off the heat. If you follow this you will have a super smooth, lump-free filling!

Stir a little butter and vanilla into the finished custard and top the chocolate ganache with sliced bananas. Pour the warm custard over the bananas, smooth the top, and place in the fridge to chill completely.

Once chilled it can be topped with fresh whipped cream and a drizzle of the reserved chocolate ganache.

The hubs snuck in a Banana Cream Pie slice I photographed the morning before his party and wholeheartedly approved. I think we’re going to try it with coconut next time. Because there WILL be a next time.

5 from 2 votes